Sunday, January 30, 2011

Van Bommel out.. who will step in his shoes?

Van Bommel, the first non-German captain officially left Bayern Munich in the winter transfer period, to AC Milan.  A bit weird that he left, 33 years old with rumors of not getting an extension & to a club where he can't play Champions League for this season on only a half a season contract.  There have been rumors that he got in a disagreement with Van Gaal, supposedly due to him loosing his starting place to Toni Kroos whose currently injured until mid-February and potentially the armband soon after.  Whether these rumors by Germany's most famous newspaper is true, I don't know but it does seem interesting.  Either way, we can thank Van Bommel for his years here but the question is who will take over his place?

Goodbye Van Bommel..

Toni Kroos is the obvious and most likely choice.  Could be the reason Van Bommel left, and I agree with Van Gaal if he sees it this way.  He can pass very very well, is excellent in the possession style of football Bayern have.  The Iniesta-Xavi combination could be the way that Schweini-Kroos may work, even though there are slight differences in positions and styles they play.. my comparison is in the way they keep possession and spray the ball around the field.  He has a good long range shot and adds something in free kicks and set pieces.  Positionally he is already great as well.  His biggest and perhaps only worry is his defensive game.  He needs to run at players more, be more aggressive and generally improve his defensive game.  He has shown glimpses of improvements but it is not at the level needed.  With Schweini by his side and Van Gaal's system however, it will be easier for him to develop.

Kroos.. working on his defensive game

There is always the option of Tymoschuk, after all Klinsmann bought him for that very reason.  He has been turned into a center back of late however, but he is always an option.  His weaknesses is that he is more of an old DM, a pure destroyer rather than the more recent players who can pass and initiate attacks much better.  However with him on the field in midfield, others like Schweinsteiger can have more freedom to attack.  Ribery and Robben wouldn't have to work as much defensively as well, but his attacking game suffers and he is not the type of player that Van Gaal prefers in that position.

 Tymoschuk or Pranjic.. could either of the two partner Schweini next?

The other choice is Luiz Gustavo, the Brazilian that came from Hoffenheim for 15m euros.  Now for this season at least, he will likely play left-back.  However after this season if Bayern sign a left-back, he could Schweini's partner.  He is a player that fits Van Gaal's system more than Tymoschuk for example, he has speed and good passing ability.  One of the best midfielders in Germany.  Another choice is Pranjic, who played very well vs United in Champions League.  Now I am a fan of Pranjic, he might even be one of my favorite players in the team.  He's not the most talented, but his devotion is praise worthy.  We bought him for 7.7m euros as a depth player, management only paid 7 million euros and Pranjic took 700,000 thousand euros from his own pocket to make sure the deal would happen.  He never complains when he is on the bench, he always gives 100% when on the field and runs all game long.  Good passer with good crossing and energetic, but I don't think he will be a starter..  he is not dominating enough in the middle of the pitch and can get muscled off the ball.  Last player left is Ottl... well he really isn't even a choice at this point.  The player could also be a new signing in the summer, who really knows what Van Gaal is thinking?

No comments:

Post a Comment